Today, the all-new 2020 BMW 4 Series made its official debut, giving the newly facelifted Audi A5 a brand-new competitor. From the looks and sounds of it, the new 4 Series will be an interesting competitor for the A5. On paper, it will be a very tough competitor but its design might be a bit too polarizing.
We obviously haven’t driven the new BMW 4 Series, as it isn’t on sale just yet, so we can’t actually compare the two cars. However, we can check out their specs and their design, to see which one looks better and which seems better on paper.
Check the Specs
On paper, the two cars are surprisingly should compete well. Both the standard Audi A5 and BMW 4 Series (not the S5 or M440i) come with a few different four-cylinder options, both gasoline and diesel. In America, the two most models will be the Audi A5 45 TFSI and the BMW 430i. The A5 makes 248 horsepower and 273 lb-ft of torque, while the 430i makes 258 horsepower and 295 lb-ft.
There’s also the Audi A5 40 TFSI and the BMW 420i for Europe, as well as the A5 40 TDI and BMW 430d. So there are smaller engines for each model, with similar power outputs and efficiency.
In Europe, the Audi A5 is offered with either front-wheel drive or all-wheel drive and either a manual transmission or an eight-speed automatic transmission. While the BMW 4 Series is only offered with an automatic, throughout the range. The Bimmer is also offered with either rear-wheel drive or all-wheel drive.
How Do They Look?
The second-generation Audi A5 is a stunning looking car, even after its mid-cycle facelift, which may have done more harm than good. While most of the 4 Series looks good, it has one big problem — its monstrous grille.
Up front, the Audi A5 is the better looking car, without a doubt. Sure, the A5 has a big grille but it’s nowhere near the leviathan-like nostrils of the 4 Series. While the Bimmer does have some redeeming features up front, such as its nice headlights are front air intakes, the A5 looks better as a whole and it’s mostly due to the grille. Still, it’s the Audi that has the better looking mug, thanks to its crisp grille lines, sharp headlights and more proportionate face.
In profile, it’s a bit closer. Both are really, really good looking cars when seen from the side and both have different attitudes about them. The BMW 4 Series is a bit sleeker, a bit more elegant and athletic. Whereas the Audi A5 seems a bit more butch, a bit more muscular and even a bit angrier. Personally, I think I’d take the styling of the 4 Series when seen in profile. It’s just that little bit prettier.
Out back, I actually have to give the 4 Series the nod, yet again. Both cars look great and I actually think that the Audi A5’s looks a smidge better. However, the Audi A5 gets disqualified due to its fake exhaust tips, while the BMW gets real ones. Even though the rest of the back end looks good, fake exhaust tips are a big killer.
The Audi A5 crawls back into the fight with its interior, though. While the BMW 4 Series has a nice interior; one that’s good looking, ergonomic, high-tech and well made; it lacks any sort of excitement. Whereas the Audi A5 looks very modern, fresh and sporty on the inside. Its materials are just as good, as are its ergonomics. So the Audi A5 has to take the interior section.
That leaves this at two-and-two. So which one is better? Well, because the 4 Series grille is a bit too obnoxious at the moment, Id personally choose the Audi A5 instead.