Auto Express Test: Audi A4 vs BMW 3 Series vs Jaguar XE

Of all it’s competitors, the current Audi A4 is among the oldest. Despite its recent facelift, the bones of the B9 A4 are still quite old. However, it’s still a good car and one that’s competitive in the segment. But can it compete with its newer rivals like the BMW 3 Series and Jaguar XE? Auto Express put the three together to find out.

In this test, all three cars use four-cylinder diesel engines, automatic gearboxes and all-wheel drive. So, on paper at least, they’re all evenly matched. However, on the road,their differences start to really crop up.

The newest car in the test is the new G20-gen BMW 3 Series and it seems to feel it. It’s the most dynamic of the three cars, with the sharpest steering and the best agility. It rides a bit stiffer than the Jaguar XE but it handles just as well and is more impressive than the Audi A4. It also has the best technology and the most practicality. So the new 3 Series takes the win.

While the Jaguar XE has the best overall driving ability, thanks to its handling that’s just as sharp as the 3 Series but with a better ride. But its subpar infotainment system and weak engine keep it from taking first place.

You Might Also Enjoy:  Audi A4 compared to BMW 3-Series and new Mercedes C-Class

That leaves the Audi A4 in last place. Overall, the A4 is a good car, with a comfortable ride, decent handling, a great interior and great cabin technology. However, its powertrain isn’t quite as good as the BMW’s, nor is its handling/ride combination. Despite being a good car overall, though, it’s just not a standout in the segment anymore, especially with such excellent competition.

Thankfully, Audi is currently working on a new A4 that will continue to be built on a longitudinal MLB architecture. So we can expect a better, more exciting A4 to be debuting in a couple of years.

[Source: Auto Express]
Nico DeMattia

I've been in love with cars since I was a kid, specifically German cars. Now I get to drive them talk about them on the internet.